Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

    Apologies in advance for the length. I got a little carried away.

    Last fall, I decided it was time to buy a real dovetail saw. I had surveyed the market some time ago and had pretty will decided to order one from Vlad Spehar but by the time I got around to placing an order he had close up his saw-making shop.

    This time I looked at the saws from Lie Neilson, Lee Valley (PAX), Adria and Mike Wentzel. Funny thing about buying dovetail saws by searching the Internet – they all look good and it’s really hard to tell which one feels and works better by looking at the pictures and reading the specs.

    Well if I couldn’t be objective, I had to be subjective. I preferred to buy Canadian - surely we can build saws just as well as the Americans. That eliminated Lie Nielson and Wentzel. The PAX saw from LV is made in Britain, but I was willing to make an exception because of the company that sold it. But it had a closed handle and that reminded me too much of my father’s old Craftsman panel saw; it looked like it would be too big and cumbersome for the fine dovetails that I envisioned myself making. So that left the Adria. Now to place the order.

    But before I got around to it, I noticed a thread or two on this forum about a dovetail saw “Ed from Oakville” was making. I contacted Ed for some more information and from the specifications he provided, it sounded just as good as all the other saws I had investigated. I also like the idea of buying a handcrafted product (there’s that subjectivity again), and I developed a mental picture of Ed labouring in his basement in Oakville wearing a leather apron and pounding out a thing of beauty with an anvil, a hammer and an open forge. After a couple more e-mails about specification and delivery, I pulled the trigger just before Christmas.

    When the saw arrived by mail just after New Year’s, it was packaged better than most of the fragile Christmas presents I sent to Calgary in early December: cardboard sheath around the blade, bubble wrap, crumpled newspaper and Styrofoam peanuts. After I liberated the saw, the first thing I noticed was its weight and how easily it came to hand (OK, that’s two things).

    The weight was just enough to make it feel like a quality tool and, I assume to help it move through the wood. But what I really liked was the way it felt in my hand. During my investigation, that was the area that gave me the most concern – how would the maker know how big my hand is? Vlad Spehar used to ask for hand measurements so he could build to suit, but he was the only one. Ed assured me he would fix whatever I didn’t like, so I thought it was worth the gamble. But no changes are required.

    When I got the saw to the shop and actually tried out the saw, it was, in a word, wonderful. The only thing I had to do was remember to keep moving it back and forth through the wood and the saw did the rest. It cut straight and effortlessly. I was happy!!

    I should say here, that I really have had no experience with any other Western dovetail saw, so at this point I had no basis for a comparison. (I do have a fine Japanese saw, but I haven’t been able to come to grips with the fact that it has to be pulled not pushed, so I keep bending it.) Coincidently, the Ottawa Woodworking Assoc. monthly meeting was coming up and one of the other members had some thoughts abut the PAX saw he had purchased, so we arranged to have a “saw off” to compare Ed’s saw, the PAX and a Lie Neilson. I spent most of my time comparing mine and the LN (I still don’t like the look of the PAX).

    In terms of a physical comparison, the LN is:
    üsmaller (blade width) and lighter
    üthe handle is also smaller, so getting a “firm” grip requires a little more squeezing
    üthe distance between the horns on the handle is a little longer so it feels sloppier in my hand

    As far as performance is concerned, I honestly couldn’t tell any difference. I didn’t take the time to count the number of strokes it took to cut a standard depth. The kerf width seems to be the same. No discernable difference in the effort required to push the saw through the wood.

    Since I already admitted that I liked my saw, I was particularly interested in what the other OWA members thought of it. After lots of sawing and discussion about the relative merits each one, I asked the group the big question. “Did I make a good choice? (I figured that was a safer question that “which do you like better?”). Overwhelmingly the answer was “YES”, particularly when I told them the price I paid (considerably less than the LN). What was particularly telling was the number of LN owners that asked for Ed’s contact information so they could discuss an order.

    For the more technically oriented people out there, here are the specs:
    üThe brass back is ¼”x ¾”x8" with a milled slot for the blade
    üThe saw blade is 0.020” thick
    üThe saw blade is 8" long and 2” wide (can be made anywhere from 1-1/2” to 2-1/2”)
    üFiled for a rip cut
    ü15 ppi. with approx 0.05" set on each side. (16ppi available)
    üHandle in Cocobolo, Padauk, QS European Beech or Spalted Apple. Others are available if Ed can find the wood

    Ed tells me that he’s investigating the possibilities of larger tenon saws and hopes to have some prototypes in the near future. But there may be a bit of a delay because he and his wife just welcomed son #3 and he may have to cut back on the anvil work for a while.

    The Readers Digest Version – I like the Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw and I’m sure you will too.
    Last edited by Paul in Ottawa; 01-12-2007, 02:08 PM.

  • #2

    Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

    Paul

    I'm looking forward to receiving mine. It sounds like Ed makes a nice product.

    Steve
    If a man speaks in the forest, and there's no woman around to hear him, is he still wrong

    Comment


    • #3

      Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

      I think you'll be happy Steve

      Comment


      • #4

        Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

        Happy Groundhog Day, Ed!

        This past summer Ed came to my Galoot BBQ and he brought a bunch of his saws. The theme this year was DT saws. We had my old saws, an "R.H. Smith Successors to J. Flint" circa 1875, and "Tyzack, Turner and Sons" from the mid 20th C, plus an Adria, a couple of Lie Nielsen copies of the Independence Tool saw (you guys do know that LN bought out the IT saw company, and they make a nice copy of the "real thing" evil grin :^) and even a Grammercy DT saw.

        We didn't actually cut any dovetails, but we made a real hash out of the ends of a couple of boards. One of the most interesting differences between the saws (apart from the 'feel' of the handles) was the angle between the grip and the blade. One of Ed's saws had a very steep angle. I don't remember which saw came out on top, but Ed's were certainly able to compete with the top of the line stuff.

        I hosted the Halton Furniture Maker's hands-on night on Tuesday, and the topic was hand-cut dovetails. Once again, a stellar group of saws was assembled on my workbench, and half a dozen through dovetail joints were cut, several of them first-time efforts. Ed was busy attending to family business (#3 son's arrival - Congratulations!) so he and his saws were conspicuously absent. They would have impressed the group I'm sure!

        Darrell
        Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

        Comment


        • #5

          Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

          love mine

          Aldo I have not used it a whole lot yet, I 'm please with everything about it. The saw itself is great, feel's good and cut great so far. The second thing that is great is the man itself that made it, after taking to ED over the phone, I shortly realized that he is a nice guys and as passion for making good quality saw. I can't wait for Ed to start making different one. If you compare the saw with other ones, the only thing that I can see is the price, low price.

          Thank's ED for the great saw and will talk soon.

          Comment


          • #6

            Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

            Just goes to show you that good guys can do well, so much of the success of many independant tool makers is based on the attitude of the tool maker to their craft and how they support their customers.....those that fail at this seldom survive.....Way to Go Ed, I need to check out the Oakville Saw makers offerings!!
            Take care,
            Jim

            My Passion
            www.pensforcanadianpeacekeepers.ca

            SPCHTsigpic

            Comment


            • #7

              Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

              Nice Review

              It's always interesting to hear about Canadian made tools. E-bay seems to have a few independent tools makers as well as past makers. Shepherd plane kits seem to be going for more money than they sold for from the maker. I personally find it really takes alot of know how and dedication to make a tool. Cheer's to Ed. Be nice to see a article in the magazine someday.

              Comment


              • #8

                Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                Good evening all, I finally have some time to respond to all the kind words from everyone. Our third son arrived Tuesday morning it has been a whirlwind week but the lord of the manor should be asleep for a couple of hours.

                Paul, I want to say thank you so much for the time and thought you obviously put into your review and I am really humbled by your post. Within our community I really feel it is a privilege to be able to make a tool a fellow woodworker will enjoy using in their workshop. It has also allowed me to meet some wonderful people on this forum like Paul, Sebastien, Edward G. (I had an opportunity to see his workshop he fondly calls "Ted's Shed" and it is something most of us can only dream about!), Steve and Rick. I've known Darrell and Jim for a few of years and both are great guys and generous teachers of woodworking.

                Steve, I've started your saws and they should be on schedule for delivery .

                I am really proud of the wonderful support and encouragement I receive from Canadian woodworkers on this forum!

                Thank you all again.

                Best regards,

                Ed

                Comment


                • #9

                  Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                  Hey Ed,
                  Congratulations on the new member to your family!
                  Frank
                  SPCHT

                  Comment


                  • #10

                    Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                    Ed - my congratulations for the addition to the family!

                    Paul - great review BUT WE MUST HAVE PICTURES!!

                    Darrell - this will interest you (possibly others too):
                    http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/d.../fatherSon.asp

                    Regards from Perth

                    Derek

                    Comment


                    • #11

                      Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                      Originally posted by derekcohen View Post
                      Ed - my congratulations for the addition to the family!

                      Paul - great review BUT WE MUST HAVE PICTURES!!

                      Darrell - this will interest you (possibly others too):
                      http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/d.../fatherSon.asp

                      Regards from Perth

                      Derek
                      Thank you for the congratulations Derek, Frank and Jim in B. I really should correct my previous post and state I am proud to have the support and encouragement of woodworkers all overy the world. I have learned and been encouraged by the dozens of tutorials and insights Derek has posted and continues to do. I also consider him a wonderful teacher .

                      This is not a picture of Paul's actual saw but it is a Cocobolo handle as he ordered. It should give you a good idea of his saw.

                      Thank you again everyone.

                      Best regards,

                      Ed
                      Attached Files

                      Comment


                      • #12

                        Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                        That's a beautiful saw, Ed. Perfect positioning of the grain. Really nice work altogether.

                        Regards from Perth

                        Derek

                        Comment


                        • #13

                          Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                          Thanks for posting that picture Ed. I was going to try and do that this morning.

                          Paul

                          Comment


                          • #14

                            Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                            Hi Paul,

                            I just ordered a LN dovetail saw. hasn't arrived yet. I paid $125 I also own an Adria saw and paid around the same price for that.

                            How much did you pay for your saw?

                            wanda
                            wanda

                            Comment


                            • #15

                              Re: Medallion Toolworks Dovetail Saw - a review

                              Wanda

                              I'm not sure what Ed's charging for his saws now, but I will almost guarantee you that it's less than either Adria or L-N, and a nicer saw than either to boot. I keep telling Ed that he's not charging enough, but I don't know if he's listening to me. Jim Shaver and I gave a bunch of his saws a bit of a workout this weekend at a one-day hand-sawing course with Chris Schwarz, and we were both very happy with Ed's saws.

                              Steve
                              If a man speaks in the forest, and there's no woman around to hear him, is he still wrong

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X